Saturday, March 2, 2013

Are Officers not Accountable for Lapses?

Navodayas have been reported to have lesser cases of sexual harassment when compared with our sister organization: KVS.  Officers in HQ, hellbent on competing with KVS, may be naturally furious  with KV scoring a few points more by having  a lot more instances of sexual harassment.  Now they can feel relieved with the latest news that the former  Principal of an Army School who was facing a legal case for sexual harassment was appointed as Principal of JNV Lalitpur in UP. Though it may not equate them with KVS, its a small step ahead!!

Jokes apart, Why the tendency to fix responsibility starts with the teachers and ends with the Principals? Why officers are not reigned in by the officers at HRD? Is there any mechanism to make them accountable for policy and administrative lapses? Recruitment Methods are so defectively devised,  the Question Papers are bilingual and English Competency is confined to 25 marks, that it led to recruitment of PGTs who can't teach well through English. English is the medium of instruction for Science subjects from Class VIII to Class XII!! Now look at the way recruitment for model schools  in AP was made.  Those who studied through Telugu medium were barred from recruitment so that the academic standards will not be negatively effected. Even High Court upheld the decision!

Teachers  who don't know the language which is the medium of instruction are recruited! No where in the world that kind of recruitment has been done!! The TGT recruitment process is another blunder. You can read about that in my previous post here.

If the lapse is at a teacher level, the damage is to the students whom he teaches or whose well being he is looking after; if the lapse is at a principal level, the damage is to that particular Vidyalaya; but the lapses at the HQ level will result  in disastrous consequences and threaten to deflate  the hard earned good will of the Samiti. Still no reasonable action can be taken against the erring officers! Results will certainly be down if the teachers can't teach them through English and the young boys and girls will feel more alienated when they find  that their House Masters( of Junior Houses) can't understand their tongue! Eventually teachers and principals will be made accountable for the consequences of these lapses !!

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Small People and Mean Methods!!

“Few will have the greatness to bend history itself, but each of us can work to change a small portion of events. It is from numberless diverse acts of courage and belief that human history is shaped.”
                                                                                                                 ― Robert F. Kennedy

Everyone one of us who held our head high and challenged the decades old officer's dadagiri by committing ourselves to the strike call given by JAC had worked to change a small portion of events. Irrational unleashing of fear had been the only and only way that was adopted by NVS Officers to run Navodayas. The strike has shaken them and hurt their egos!

Had Samiti opened and maintained a dialogue before the strike had started with sincerity,it would have not shown them in such a poor light. Divide and Rule is an ancient trick! Pretend as if nothing is happening while your house is on fire is so stupid!

A resourceful minister, being at the helm, has saved Samiti from opening one of the most self destructive methods  that they would have resorted to!   Had  Reddy failed to rope in the political leadership to check the ivory tower bureaucracy's autocratic gestures, things would have taken ugly turn leaving the employees feeling bitter. Strike was gracefully called off!

Still Samiti has shown its true colors by serving suspension orders on lower level workers while the leaders  deliberated with the Minister! Isn't it called Cowardice? Promises of revocation of suspensions had remained promises until the Minister was again approached!

Time only will tell us, whether anything positive will come out of the strike in terms of resolution of demands. What the strike has achieved  is the freeing of the people from fear! The suspensions and delay in revocation clearly shows the desperation of Samiti to keep the fear psychosis intact!

Monday, January 21, 2013

We Never Learn From History!


"We learn from history that we learn nothing from history."
                                                          George Bernard Shaw
The way the mud slinging game has been unfolding in Samiti about the Supreme Court case is a living example for the often quoted words of Shaw. One SLP and two Writ Petitions have been filed in Supreme Court and all the cases will be pooled under a single bench. First SLP was an appeal by Mishra after his case failed in Jharkhand High Court.  The first Writ Petition was filed by Kannan & others from Pune Region and  later was filed by the General Secratary, AINVSA (LBREDDY). Had we learnt from History, this would have been a wonderful opportunity as three different sets of legal brains would have  fought for a common cause with proper co-ordination.


But we never learn from history. Pune Region has sent a legal notice to Mishra seeking the refund of the contributions which they have contributed for case in Ranchi High Court. AINSVA has circulated a letter asking not to yield to the coarsen of offcergiri.(taking a dig at the Principals and Officers of Pune Region) The latest is the unsigned  letter defending the case filed by Kannan and others and questioning the leadership of Reddy.


Why can't Pune Region take up the case with its own resources instead of demanding refund from Mishra who has been fighting for Pension for a long time. Why can't Mr Reddy gather resources from other regions who have not been contributing to Pune Region's case instead of  busying himself in another round of inner fighting? Why can't the Officers and Principals of Pune Region ignore the rants of Reddy  and go ahead with their case showing their magnanimity? Why can't all the three cases be utilized for realization of our ultimate goal. Co operation and co ordination is the need of the hour, not the inner fighting and ugly display of super egos!